Former Juventus midfielder Angelo Di Livio has delivered a blunt assessment of Federico Chiesa’s career at Liverpool, insisting the Italian winger made the wrong decision by moving to Anfield while questioning the quality and mentality of Juventus’ current squad.

Di Livio believes Chiesa still possesses the talent to make a significant impact at the highest level but fears his career has stalled because of his limited opportunities in England. He has also suggested that a return to Italian football, potentially with AS Roma, could help the forward rediscover his best form.

Speaking to Retesport, the former Italy international did not hide his opinion about Chiesa’s move to Liverpool.

“Chiesa made a mistake joining Liverpool,” Di Livio said.

However, his criticism was accompanied by a clear show of confidence in the winger’s ability. Di Livio argued that a player with Chiesa’s technical qualities does not simply lose his talent and believes the 28-year-old needs the right environment and regular playing time to get his career back on track.

He also identified Roma as a potential destination, suggesting that playing under Gian Piero Gasperini could help Chiesa regain his place in the Italian national team.

Chiesa’s Liverpool Struggle Raises Questions

Chiesa arrived at Liverpool from Juventus in August 2024, hoping to establish himself in the Premier League after an inconsistent final period in Turin.

The move offered him the opportunity to test himself at one of Europe’s biggest clubs. However, his time at Anfield has been frustrating, with injuries, competition for attacking positions and limited minutes restricting his ability to build momentum.

Despite making contributions when given opportunities, Chiesa has struggled to secure a consistent role in Liverpool’s starting eleven. His situation has also raised questions about whether remaining in England is the best decision for a player eager to revive his international career.

The winger previously helped Italy win the European Championship in 2021 and was widely regarded as one of the country’s most exciting attacking talents. Reaching that level again will likely require more than occasional appearances from the bench.

A return to Serie A could provide a fresh opportunity, particularly if a club is prepared to build its attacking plans around his strengths. Nevertheless, any potential transfer would depend on the interests of Liverpool, the player's own ambitions and the terms of a possible deal.

Di Livio Delivers Brutal Verdict on Juventus

Chiesa was not the only subject of Di Livio’s criticism. The former Juventus star also expressed serious concerns about the club he represented with distinction during his playing career.

Following Juventus’ 2-0 defeat to Genoa, Di Livio questioned the overall quality of the squad available to Luciano Spalletti and suggested that the club’s problems extend beyond the manager.

“The squad is poor, there are players unworthy of wearing the Bianconeri jersey,” he said.

Di Livio was particularly troubled by what he perceived as a lack of urgency and accountability surrounding the team’s disappointing performances. He contrasted the current atmosphere with the demanding standards he experienced during his own time in Turin, when expectations were exceptionally high.

While acknowledging that Spalletti has some responsibility for the team's struggles, Di Livio argued that the quality of the players assembled must also come under scrutiny.

His comments highlight a familiar debate surrounding Juventus: whether the club’s difficulties are primarily the result of managerial decisions, recruitment shortcomings or a wider decline in the standards that once made the Italian giants one of Europe's most feared sides.

Juventus Face Questions About Their Identity

For a club with Juventus’ history, disappointing results often bring more than criticism of tactics and individual performances. They also raise questions about mentality, leadership and what it means to represent the black and white shirt.

Di Livio’s comments reflect the frustration of a former player who experienced Juventus during a period of considerable domestic and European success. His criticism suggests that, in his view, the current squad has yet to demonstrate the consistency and character associated with the club’s greatest teams.

Whether his assessment proves fair over the longer term remains to be seen. Football squads can improve significantly with the right recruitment, tactical adjustments and greater confidence, but Juventus will need to demonstrate that they can respond to setbacks rather than allow them to define their season.

For Chiesa, meanwhile, the coming months could prove equally important. His talent remains unquestioned by Di Livio, but regular football will be essential if he is to rebuild his reputation and return to the centre of Italy’s plans.

The January transfer window could therefore become a decisive moment for both the winger and Juventus, with a possible return to Serie A offering Chiesa a route back to regular football while his former club continues searching for answers to its own problems.

Enhance your team analysis and make more informed decisions. Visit Sentra AI for match predictions and insights.